New York (especially the New York City metro) is one of the highest-cost places to live in the United States. Myrtle Beach and the surrounding Horry County area in South Carolina are significantly more affordable for most households, particularly retirees and people relocating from the Northeast. Housing is the biggest driver of the gap, followed by property taxes and the way South Carolina treats Social Security and retirement income.
Here is a clear, practical breakdown of the major cost-of-living differences.

1. Overall Cost of Living: Myrtle Beach Is Substantially Lower
Multiple independent cost-of-living comparisons (updated through late 2026) show New York City is roughly 75% to 150% more expensive than Myrtle Beach when rent or mortgage costs are included. A single person typically spends about $2,450–$2,500 per month in Myrtle Beach versus roughly $4,900–$5,000 in New York City. Couples and families see similar proportional gaps.
Outside of housing, the differences are smaller but still favor Myrtle Beach in most categories. Everyday costs (groceries, dining, services) are generally closer to or slightly below the national average in the Myrtle Beach area, while New York remains well above it.
For a full local breakdown, see the Cost of Living in Myrtle Beach guide on HomeGuideMyrtleBeach.com.
2. Housing: The Largest Savings Category
Housing is where most of the money is saved. One-bedroom apartment rents in the Myrtle Beach area commonly run $1,200–$1,600 per month (higher near the ocean or in newer amenity-heavy communities). Comparable units in New York City frequently exceed $3,000–$4,500+.
Home purchase prices show an even larger gap. Many solid single-family homes and townhomes in Horry County (especially inland areas such as Carolina Forest, Longs, Conway, and parts of Socastee) fall in the $300,000–$450,000 range. Median and typical prices in New York City and many of its suburbs are several times higher.
Location inside the Grand Strand still matters. Inland and northern areas generally offer better value than oceanfront or high-resort communities. Compare options in the Best Myrtle Beach Neighborhoods for Retirees and the broader Best Neighborhoods in the Myrtle Beach Area guides.
3. Property Taxes: Much Lower for Primary Residences in South Carolina
South Carolina assesses primary residences (legal residence) at a 4% ratio and provides a homestead exemption for qualifying homeowners age 65 and older (currently the first $50,000 of fair market value is exempt; confirm current rules and application with the county). Owner-occupied homes are also generally exempt from school operating millage.
As a result, annual property tax bills on a typical $350,000–$400,000 primary home in unincorporated Horry County or North Myrtle Beach are often in the low four figures—frequently $1,000–$2,000 depending on exact location and exemptions. New York effective property tax rates are substantially higher statewide (around 1.3% in recent data), and many suburban and downstate areas produce much larger bills.
Always get an address-specific estimate. Details are covered in:
- What Are Myrtle Beach Property Taxes Like?
- South Carolina Homestead Exemption Guide
- Myrtle Beach Property Taxes, Insurance & Flood Zones
4. State Income Taxes and Retirement Income Treatment
South Carolina does not tax Social Security benefits at any income level. Residents age 65 and older also receive a retirement income deduction (up to $10,000 per person on qualifying pension/IRA/401(k) income) plus an additional age-65 deduction (up to $15,000 of any South Carolina taxable income, reduced by the retirement deduction claimed). Military retirement is fully exempt.
New York taxes retirement income more heavily in most cases, and its overall state and local tax burden is higher. These differences are a major reason many retirees from the Northeast consider South Carolina. Related reading: Why Are Retirees Leaving Florida for Myrtle Beach / Horry County? and the Cost of Living in Myrtle Beach article.
5. Groceries, Dining, and Everyday Expenses
Groceries and restaurant meals are generally more expensive in New York City than in Myrtle Beach. Independent comparisons typically show grocery costs 40%+ higher and dining out 30–45% higher in New York. The Myrtle Beach area usually sits near or modestly below the national average for these categories.
Utilities can run higher in Myrtle Beach during peak summer air-conditioning months, but this rarely offsets the housing and tax savings for most households.
6. Insurance: Location Matters More Than the State Name
Standard homeowners insurance (including wind) is often reasonable inland in Horry County but can rise significantly closer to the coast or in flood zones. Flood insurance is a separate policy and depends on the specific property’s FEMA zone and elevation. Oceanfront or high-risk properties frequently see the largest insurance costs.
In many cases the all-in monthly cost (mortgage or paid-off status + taxes + insurance + HOA) still favors Myrtle Beach versus New York, but buyers should obtain insurance quotes before making an offer. See the Myrtle Beach Property Taxes, Insurance & Flood Zones guide and the condo HOA/insurance article for more detail.
7. HOA Fees and Community Costs
Many single-family neighborhoods in the Myrtle Beach area have low or no HOA fees ($0–$150 per month). Amenity-heavy or 55+ communities commonly range higher. Oceanfront and resort condos can carry substantially larger monthly fees that include more services.
The key is what the fee covers versus what you would pay separately. For a practical look at whether an HOA makes sense for retirees, read Should retirees buy in an HOA in Horry County?.
8. Transportation, Healthcare, and Lifestyle Trade-offs
Transportation costs are typically lower in the Myrtle Beach area than in the New York metro (less reliance on public transit fares or high parking costs; car ownership is more common). Healthcare access is solid in the Grand Strand region, though the density of specialists can differ from major New York medical centers.
The lifestyle trade-off is intentional for most relocators: lower ongoing costs, mild winters, beaches, golf, and a slower pace versus the density, cultural amenities, and higher salaries of New York. Many full-time residents choose inland or northern areas (Carolina Forest, Longs, North Myrtle Beach, Conway) for the best balance of cost and convenience. Compare these options in the Carolina Forest vs Longs vs Conway vs North Myrtle Beach guide and the North Myrtle Beach vs Myrtle Beach for Retirement article.
Bottom Line
Myrtle Beach and Horry County are meaningfully less expensive than New York for most households, with the largest advantages in housing costs, property taxes on a primary residence, and the treatment of Social Security and other retirement income. The exact savings depend on the specific neighborhood, property type (house vs condo), insurance zone, and whether the home will be a primary residence.
Run the full monthly number—principal and interest (or zero if paid cash), taxes after 4% legal residence and any homestead exemption, homeowners + wind insurance, flood insurance if required, HOA, and utilities—before deciding. For personalized numbers and current inventory, contact the Jerry Pinkas Real Estate Experts team through HomeGuideMyrtleBeach.com or call 843-839-9870.
Data points drawn from publicly available cost-of-living comparisons (including CityCost, MyLifeElsewhere, and local market reports), current as of late 2026. Individual results vary by address, property type, and personal circumstances.